33 Comments

First of all- I am triggered every time I see a Gen Z at a bar in sneakers. If they only KNEW the fresh hell us elder millennials had to endure in our clippity clop clop heels….we were like a pack of tortured Clydesdales. Second! If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it! There’s a reason this is such a classic formula and love that you gave it some attention. 🖤💙

Expand full comment

Hahahaha, yes you’re so right! I’m probably still undoing years of damage from stumbling around in heels, and thank goodness I never needed a tetanus shot from giving up and walking home barefoot at the end of the night!

Expand full comment

Lindsay; so many thoughts that I'm getting them out in stream of consciousness form....

"Ha! I've heard that A&F used to ban black, perhaps because I couldn't afford A&F as a teen that underlies my obsession with black. Wait, she works at Tommy Hilfiger, how did I not know this? HAHAHA that picture is hilarious. Hold on, jeans and a black tee looks great. I remember seeing that Note from Katie about her outfit and I thought she looked so so chic (her hair! her skin!). Where are these cute kick flare JEANS from (immediately locate and click link). WHAT Lindsay included my post in her round up, she's the best! Ooh a dress suggestion... SANDRO... GORGEOUS!"

Ok that's all.

Expand full comment

ILYSM!! This was the perfect recap of this post lol! I should share as the teaser 😂 Hope you had a fab time at your event!!

Expand full comment

😂 I’m glad you liked it. Hopefully it captured how much I LOVE your writing.

Expand full comment

Greatest compliment you could give a gal, thank you!!

Expand full comment

Bless you for putting the words around this. I've always just thought of denim+black as kind of a failsafe, low-effort / med-high pay off but now that I feel like it's a THING I am going to get a lot more oomph into it. Need to know what Abercrombie had against purple. Like- was lavender ok? Or was the entire color off limits. This is going to haunt me. I hate purple as a sports team color (Vikings, Furman, ahem) but I love it otherwise.

Expand full comment

It’s a thing! And to bring it back to last week’s post, you can go evergreen, key, or big hitter with it to really get the full mileage! It was ALL purple, all shades. It wasn’t “preppy” apparently?? (TBH Tommy H. doesn’t love purple either but it’s not banned lol). Lavender definitely more ok than royal! I’m also not a big purple fan (might have been scarred by my freshman year at Williams College, which was purple and gold, yeesh.) Might this need to be a whole post in the future?

Expand full comment

“Purple isn’t preppy” feels like a challenge

Expand full comment

Let’s do it! New Year’s Resolution 2025 😂

Expand full comment

I will never give up my jeans and a going out top!! Love this reframe and how you can play/tweak a classic - going to be stealing "nice but not too flashy"!

Expand full comment

Thanks Amanda! Long live jeans and a going out top!

Expand full comment

I am in my 50s and have been wearing this combination in various forms since the 90s. So this is nothing new. 🤷🏼‍♀️

Expand full comment

Totally! Those 90s photos of Kate and Carolyn are iconic! I had some images from the 70s I was going to share, too, but needed to edit 😉

Expand full comment

I grew up in the San Francisco Bay Area and lived in San Francisco for a while, so that was the uniform since I can remember.

Expand full comment

Love it

Expand full comment

I wanted to send you a photo of me from 1990 but it looks like there’s no way to do it but I’m dressed with a going out top in black and jeans.

Expand full comment

Ah! I wish I could see it - I’m sure it’s fabulous :)

Expand full comment

Respond to me on Instagram messages and I’ll send it to you after you respond back.

Expand full comment

Took my daughter to the movies last week. What did I wear: black v-neck gap sweater, wide-leg dark denim, leopard loafers. It always works! Great article!

Expand full comment

I’m definitely recreating your look! I have all the ingredients! Thank you! (What movie did you guys see?)

Expand full comment

Wicked, finally

Expand full comment

Oh the irony that you couldn’t wear black to work — I had the opposite; wearing color was considered offensive at Calvin hahaha.

Expand full comment

Still is, I think, haha!!

Expand full comment

Abso-freaking-lutely!!

Expand full comment

So fun! Thanks for the shout out — and for the amazing barrel jeans recs 👀👀👀👀

Expand full comment

Thanks, Kate! Love your work!

Expand full comment

I’ve been saving this post and it is so spot-on. I love the simplicity of jeans and a black too and I’m obsessed with that black velvet Mango option you shared.

I find lately that my wardrobe takes two divergent paths depending on whether I’m at home in our traditionally Lockjaw town, or if I’m in the city. This is a perfect city formula for me!

One top to add to your list: Frame just sent me a great black tee with lace sleeves that is SO good.

Expand full comment

Thank you, Sarah! I’m so glad you enjoyed it! That Frame top sounds delightful, and I love something that will work year round! Festive for now, and just pretty and lighter weight with the lace sleeves for later! Perfect city look!

Expand full comment

Omg this is so sweet thank you for the shoutout

Expand full comment

I really love your work!

Expand full comment

Love it!!! I love our elder millennial jeans and a going out top. I wish it were easier to find more fun going out tops now!

We contain multitudes. Sometimes we want a playful fun outfit. Sometimes we want to reach for the reliable classics that make us feel confident and comfortable immediately. ❤️

Expand full comment

Absolutely! And we should embrace it all. That’s why although I love uniform dressing, I feel like we need myriad uniforms! And yes, it’s hard to find good, going out tops that are well made but not too expensive!

Expand full comment